Letting Go of 3G - A Viable Alternative for Asian Carriers


Most Asian cellular carriers mulling over 3G have chalked out at least tentative transition paths towards that Holy Grail. If they're GSM networks, it's a safe bet EDGE (Enhanced Data for GSM Evolution) is being considered, to replace/augment GPRS for high speed data services. Because EDGE uses a new modulated scheme that is also used for UMTS/3G, EDGE becomes a sort of half-way house to 3G.

The cost to introduce 3G into an existing GSM network is enormous. A large portion of 3G's non-license related costs pertain to new nodes patched into an existing GSM network to make it 3G compliant. And of course, these new nodes need to inter-operate with existing 2G and 2.5G nodes.

An alternative does exist, that until recently dare not speak its name. Marrying cellular and WiMax/WiFi clouds, is not just cheaper, but more in keeping with the times. Besides the cost benefits, such a union addresses two other big issues: bringing high speed data services with laser like precision to the urban users who need them and voice connectivity over cell phones to suburban residential homes with poor cellular reception.

Integrating selected WiFi Hot spots or WiMax Hot Zones into a cellular network requires an IP Network Controller (INC), an IP access network, a patch to allow the Wireless LAN (WLAN) access network to issue the relevant accounting information to the cellular cloud's AAA (authentication, authorization, and accounting) server and an investment in IP roaming. Barring a few more widgets, that's essentially it.

Given the simplicity of such a solution, anyone who has seen engineers sweat over cell site deployment or attempted to work the math behind the cellular hex grid, has to wonder why the cell phone-wallahs have not already adopted WiFi/WiMax at their peripheries.

One however continues to sense discomfort in cellular circles over any open discussion on WiFi/WiMax. This may have something to do with the fact that the same user who demands everything be free on the Internet, is more than willing to pay a premium for his mobile service. The cellular carrier therefore, is understandably wary of encouraging bad habits in his paying customers.

Kineto, an equipment manufacturer, explains how such an eco-system would work.

- A subscriber with a WLAN, dual mode mobile phone moves within range of an access point to which the handset can connect.

- On attaching, the handset contacts the mobile operator's INC over the IP access network, to be authenticated and authorized for mobile service access.

- If approved, the INC updates the subscriber's location information in the network. From that point on, all mobile traffic is routed via the INC and over the IP access network. The subscriber is now on Voice over Broadband (VoB) and on a lower fixed line / VoB type tariff.

- When the subscriber moves outside the range of the serving access point, the INC facilitates roaming to the licensed outdoor network. The roaming process is completely transparent to the mobile subscriber.

- In addition, if a subscriber is on an active voice call or handset data session when they come within range (or out of range) of a service access point, the INC facilitates the handover of the active call between networks. The handover is completely transparent to the mobile subscriber.

- The WLAN access network issues the relevant accounting information to the cellular network's AAA server. This accounting information can then be incorporated into the operator's specific CDRs enabling it to be assimilated into the operator's existing legacy billing system, creating a single bill for Cellular and WLAN usage.

In divvying up responsibilities, the WLAN provider manages the network while the mobile operator looks after customer care and billing. The end-user pays his mobile operator for the usage of the WLAN. The charges for using a cell phone over a WLAN would be lower than cellular use but in most cases it would be incremental revenue that the cellular companies would otherwise lose to fixed-line or VoB networks.

The cellular-WiFi/WiMax eco system also ropes in homes and offices equipped with broadband. To connect, the home or office user goes to his mobile provider's web portal and registers his WLAN into the IP Network Controller (INC). The subscriber's cell phone is now patched into the WLAN and on a lower fixed line / Voice over Boradband (VoB) type tariff.

While there is growing competition in the VoB sector, only the cell phone operator decides whether the customer can get a combined cellular+VoB bill. A mobile provider's Cellular-WLAN service shall therefore, stand head over shoulders over any Vonage type VoB service.

As we have seen, in a Cellular-WLAN eco system devices intelligently pick and choose from the wireless network offering the strongest signal or lowest price in a given area. It is a compelling picture that demands the cellular operator's attention, more so in Asia.

****************
References & recommended reading

Books:
GPRS Demystified by Hoffman, John
GSM, GPRS and EDGE Performance : Evolution Towards 3G/UMTS
by Timo Halonen (Editor), Javier Romero (Editor), Juan Melero (Editor)
WLANs and WPANs towards 4G Wireless by Ramjee Prasad, Luis Munoz

White papers
Public Wireless LANs for Mobile Operators by Philippe Laine of Alcatel.
GSM to 3G, Evolution or revolution? by Hughes Software Systems & Adax
Europe Limited.
Handover between WCDMA and GSM by Gertie Alsenmyr,Joakim Bergstrom & others of Ericsson

Websites
http://www.gsmworld.com
http://www.cdg.org
http://www.kinetowireless.com
*********************

BRAHAM SINGH joined PCCW in January 2001 and founded their international IP backbone & service company now called BtNAccess after its merger with Corporate Access, one of Asia's largest satellite based service provider. Today, BtNAccess is an established global carrier, offering enterprise & carrier grade services over its MPLS enabled network. Services offered include IP transit, MPLS data circuits/VPNs, voice as well as a leading edge Hosted IP PBX services. The Company is interconnected with 35 carriers globally and its revenues come from an enterprise and carrier customer base in The USA, Europe, Middle East, Africa and Asia.

Braham came to PCCW from Teleglobe, where he was the Vice President in charge of Asian operations. Prior to Teleglobe, Braham was the Vice President - SE Asia for Sprint / Global One.

Braham has various pioneering achievements to his credit including the first call- back as well as the first ISR launch in Hong Kong, the first Asian frame relay launch outside Japan, the first international connectivity provided to Celcom in Malaysia in 1992.







Related News



Mobile Security Expert: Your Camera Phone Got Hacked - ZDNet UK

Mobile Security Expert: Your Camera Phone Got Hacked
ZDNet UK, UK -33 minutes ago
As the quality of mobile phone cameras continues to advance, that is exactly why mobile hackers are targeting camera phones. Celebrities are becoming hot ...

A Bad Mix - Cell Phones and Children? - GNIF Brain Blogger

GNIF Brain Blogger

A Bad Mix - Cell Phones and Children?
GNIF Brain Blogger, CA -2 hours ago
I think it’s important to note though that the study could not make any safety statements regarding children and cell phone usage. Therefore, since there is ...

Review: iPhone 3G (Génial!) - Wi-Fi Planet

BusinessWeek

Review: iPhone 3G (Génial!)
Wi-Fi Planet, CT -Jul 24, 2008
"Any cell phone will do that," she said. Of course. But for me, talking to people who are far away is the least interesting thing about any cell phone, ...
Review: New iPhone lives up to the hypeVancouver Sun
From the Los Angeles TimesNewsday
Lab test: Apple gets iPhone 3G right for businessTMCnet
Business Edge - Wall Street Journal Blogs
all 82 news articles

New player joins NYC cell phone competition - Crian's New York Business

New player joins NYC cell phone competition
Crian's New York Business, NY -41 minutes ago
And options for cheap, pre-paid cell phone plans already exist from Virgin Mobile, TracFone and Sprint’s Boost Mobile. “MetroPCS will have to demonstrate ...
Pay By The DayNorth American Press Syndicate
all 3 news articles

MasterCard to Enable P-to-P Mobile Payments by Cell Phone - Banktech

MasterCard to Enable P-to-P Mobile Payments by Cell Phone
Banktech -22 hours ago
The interest is there to bring mobile payment capability to the market." Pugh emphasizes the convenience of p-to-p payments via cell phone. ...


OKI Safety Mobile Phone Helps Prevent Vehicular Accidents - Gearlog

OKI Safety Mobile Phone Helps Prevent Vehicular Accidents
Gearlog, NY -8 hours ago
Oki presented the prototype of a cell phone equipped with a DSRC-based automotive communication device (DSRC is a standard for inter-vehicle communications) ...

Doom'ing The iPhone - Forbes

Doom'ing The iPhone
Forbes, NY -7 hours ago
By contrast, the sweet spot for traditional cellphone games was around 300 kilobytes. Carmack wiggled around those rules of thumb and has produced a 2.5 MB ...
Doom creator speaks on iPhone developmentMacNN
all 4 news articles

Stephen King’s “N.” short story becomes cell phone serial - Slippery Brick

Wall Street Journal

Stephen King’s “N.” short story becomes cell phone serial
Slippery Brick, OR -1 hour ago
The story is called “N.” and will be offered to viewers on mobile phones and via the Internet. Bringing “N.” to the small screen required a partnership ...
Stephen King Enlists Marvel in Video PlotWall Street Journal
all 14 news articles

Babble Rouser - Forbes

Babble Rouser
Forbes, NY -19 hours ago
He dipped into the cell phone business in 1995 when he won a license in Ireland to set up a mobile phone network, Esat Telecom. ...

Cancer doctor cites 'early' data on cell phone danger - Register

China Daily

Cancer doctor cites 'early' data on cell phone danger
Register, UK -19 hours ago
In a memo sent by University of Pittsburgh Cancer Institute director Dr. Ronald Herbman yesterday, he cautions mobile phone users should not to let a lack ...
Institute head’s mobile phone scareNature.com (subscription)
Prominent Cancer Researcher Warns about Cell Phone Cancer RiskeFluxMedia
Scientist tells Israelis: Hang up your cell phones alreadyHa'aretz
InformationWeek - Slashdot
all 858 news articles